← Back to articles · Hobby & visiting shops ·
Insurance appraisals vs a shop bid: pay for the paper you actually need
A written replacement value is a paid document. A cash bid is an offer. Do not ask for the first and expect it to be the second, for free.
“Can you write down what this is worth for my insurance?”
Yes, if that is a service they offer. Yes, it often has a fee. No, that number will not match a cash bid. Appraisal vs cash bid.
Replacement
What it would cost to buy another one at retail in a reasonable time. Higher.
Cash bid
What they will pay today. Lower. Why spreads exist. Bid and ask.
If you only need a rider
Ask your insurer what they accept. Sometimes photos plus invoices are enough. Sometimes they want a formal appraisal. Do not surprise a busy Saturday counter with 400 coins and “just jot a total.” What to bring. Estates. Receipts.
More on the coin and money library.
A lawyer’s file usually needs a written bid, not a verbal Saturday number.
Extra pad history for insurance paper vs a bid
Insurance paper and cash have always been different jobs. A replacement number asks what it would cost to buy another one at retail in a reasonable time. A bid asks what this shop will pay today. Those two numbers are supposed to disagree. If they matched, the shop could not stay open and the insurer would be writing checks for melt.
Shops that write formal appraisals often charge a fee because the paper has to survive a claim, a lawyer, or an heir. A Saturday verbal “about this much” is not that paper. A lawyer’s file usually needs a written bid, not a vibe.
What the shop will and will not write
Ask what you actually need. A rider sometimes wants photos and invoices, not a bound appraisal. Receipts you already have may be enough. Do not surprise a busy Saturday with 400 coins and “just jot a total.” What to bring. Sort first if it is an estate.
If you want a cash bid, say cash bid. If you want replacement, say replacement, and expect a fee. Why buy and sell prices differ. Greysheet is a wholesale sheet, not your insurance page. We are not your insurer and this is not legal advice. It is how the paper is used on this pad.
People also ask
Will the cash bid match the appraisal? No. That is the point of the two papers.
Can I use a shop bid to argue with an insurer? Sometimes as a data point. Ask the insurer what they accept.
Do you appraise 400 coins while I wait? Not as a favor on Saturday. Make an appointment.
Is a photo inventory enough? Sometimes for a rider. Ask the insurer, not the shop’s guess.